GoHotelly
2-star hotel

Motel 57

Stay at Motel 57, a 4.3-star LGBTQ+ friendly motel in Sturgeon Bay, WI. Enjoy easy access to Potawatomi State Park and local attractions with 238 guest reviews.

1161 Green Bay Rd, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, United States View on map
8.6/10
Very Good Based on 239 recent guest reviews
Free Wi-Fi Free parking Accessible Air-conditioned Pet-friendly
What recent guests emphasize

Comfortable, Clean, and Quaint with Thoughtful Amenities

Recent visitors appreciate the motel’s nostalgic charm and value, highlighting cleanliness, spacious renovated rooms, and convenient kitchenettes. Some note seasonal cooling challenges but praise the friendly, accommodating staff and pet-friendly environment.

Guests often praise

  • Clean and comfortable rooms with good water pressure and updated bathrooms
  • Spacious accommodations including small kitchenettes stocked with utensils and appliances
  • Friendly and helpful staff making check-in and stays smooth
  • The motel’s quaint, retro ambiance and well-kept outdoor seating and parking areas
  • Pet friendliness, with a welcoming attitude toward dogs and easy outdoor access

Worth knowing

  • Air conditioning may not fully handle summer humidity, a common issue locally
  • Room experiences can vary; some guests found recent rooms less impressive than prior stays
  • Simple, mom-and-pop style motel, not a luxury property
  • Laundry facilities available for guest use at a small additional cost

Best for

  • Travelers seeking good value and a clean, no-frills stay
  • Visitors looking for a quiet, retro-style motel with a personable atmosphere
  • Pet owners wanting a welcoming place for dogs with easy outdoor access
  • Guests wanting convenient access to local outdoor activities and museums
  • LGBTQ+ travelers appreciating an inclusive and friendly environment
Compare booking partners

Open this hotel on the platform you trust.

GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.

Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.

About this property

Welcome to Motel 57

Located at 1161 Green Bay Rd in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin, Motel 57 offers a blend of motel comfort and hotel amenities with a 4.3-star rating based on 238 reviews. The property is noted for its clean, spacious rooms that include kitchenettes, making it suitable for visitors seeking convenience and practicality. Guests frequently mention the motel’s retro charm and the quiet, welcoming atmosphere created by the friendly staff.

The motel’s layout allows guests to park directly in front of their rooms, featuring outdoor seating areas and shared facilities like grills and a laundry room, which add to the convenience for longer stays or group visits. While some reviewers have noted minor inconsistencies in room quality, the overall experience is described as good value, especially for those who prefer a low-key alternative to large commercial hotels.

Motel 57 is LGBTQ+ friendly, welcoming a diverse range of guests. Its location serves well for those interested in sightseeing and recreational activities, supported by a mid-level score for ease of getting around. Nearby attractions include Potawatomi State Park and the Door County Maritime Museum, both popular for outdoor activities and cultural exploration. The Green Bay Austin Straubel International Airport is about a 52-minute drive away, facilitating access for travelers.

The property’s surroundings include several other lodging options within a few miles, providing choices depending on style and budget. Guest feedback highlights the motel as a sensible base for exploring Door County, especially for visitors who enjoy a calm setting with practical amenities like strong water pressure and pet-friendly policies.

Summary compiled by GoHotelly editors from verified guest reviews, partner descriptions and editorial notes.
Facilities & essentials

What's on-site and what you should know before you arrive

The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.

Most popular facilities

Free Wi-Fi
Free parking
Accessible
Air-conditioned
Pet-friendly
Kid-friendly
Kitchen in all rooms

Not available at this property

Breakfast
Pool
Restaurant
Airport shuttle
Fitness center
Verified guest reviews

What recent guests are actually saying

Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.

RJ
R. Janke Mar 29, 2026
10

Another Retro vibe motel. That seemed to be a theme for us on this vacation. As I've said in previous reviews we're not looking for "luxury". Clean, good showers, comfortable bed, good value..... We're good. We'll be staying here again.

JRF
J. R. Frost Mar 28, 2026
8.0

Stayed here before and had a better room experience. The rooms are clean, equipment works, the motel is a great value for the price. I was just slightly disappointed in the room this time based on the spectacular room last time.

JS
Jacqueline Sweeney Mar 18, 2026
10

Let me start by stating, we are so happy to have stayed here. This motel brought back wonderful memories of years past. The motel was extremely clean, the check in/check out was a breeze. This place is so quaint. It was an absolute wonderful change from staying at the large commercial places which make you feel unappreciated. We highly recommend this place! Bonus...it's a mom and pops...even better!! Almost forgot, AMAZING water pressure!!

DS
Daniela Sumner Feb 11, 2026
10

We drove by this place a million times, never giving it any attention. For our current trip it it showed up with a great rating and an even better price on a booking site, so we thought we give it a try and boy are we glad we did. The rooms are spacious and completely renovated. The kitchenette is awesome and completely stocked with all the supplies you could need. The bathroom and shower are also great. Good pressure and instant warm water. We are really excited about this find and it will now become our 1st go to. Let me not forget the staff, because they are wonderful as well. Thank you for a great stay.

DS
Dottie Sexton Jan 18, 2026
10

We have always enjoyed our stays here. They are great about our 2 dogs and the dogs always like being here as well. The only complaint I have is the air conditioners don't keep up with the humidity in the room in the summer months, but I find that at several places in Door county in the summer :(. I also want to say: Thank you for the kind postcard I have received for Christmas! Great people, Great Location, Great for dog owners.

CJ
cassandra jenkins Jan 16, 2026
10

This motel is soo cute! The outside area is perfect you can park your car right in front of your room there is also seating area in front of each room. Grills available outside and a laundry room that takes $2.00 per load. Our room has a small kitchenette with a hot plate and full set of utensils/plates, 2 beds and a fold out bar. This room was absolutely perfect! I have enjoyed our stay so far and the staff are incredibly friendly. I am only traveling from Washington but if I come to Sturgeon Bay again I will definitely be back!!

JP
James Pozdro Jan 12, 2026
10

Clean and quiet and close to the Door peninsula offerings without all the noise, crowds, and extra costs. The best bang for your buck when it comes to accommodations in Door county.!

JK
Julia Kvit Jan 09, 2026
8.0

This was a quaint little place outside of Sturgeon Bay. Stayed here for one night. The room was shockingly clean and neat, with a 50's-ish aesthetic. The fold up table was pretty handy, and so was the kitchen space. This place also had a big yard in the back, so walking our dog was easy.

Location & neighborhood

Where you'll find Motel 57

Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin, USA

Based on sightseeing, recreation, and getting around

  • Green Bay Austin Straubel International Airport 52 min Car
Things to do nearby

Worth the walk or a quick ride

Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Wisconsin. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.

Potawatomi State Park 1,506 reviews

Potawatomi State Park

3740 Park Dr, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, United States

4.7 · State Park
Door County Maritime Museum 1,193 reviews

Door County Maritime Museum

120 N Madison Ave, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, United States

4.6 · Museum
Miller Art Museum 18 reviews

Miller Art Museum

107 S 4th Ave, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, United States

4.7 · Museum
People also viewed

Similar Motels in Wisconsin

Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.

617 Northside Blvd, Nampa, ID 83687, United States

NAMPA INN AND SUITES

Stay at NAMPA INN AND SUITES in Nampa, ID. Enjoy free WiFi, outdoor pool, petfriendly rooms, and easy access to Warhawk Air Muse...

2.4 (643) View
1083 Pit Rd, Java Center, NY 14082, United States

Biggest Loser Resort Niagara

Stay at Biggest Loser Resort Niagara, a 4.6star wellness hotel in Java Center, NY. Enjoy spa, fitness center, pool, caloriecontr...

4.6 (47) View
1041 Wake Towne Dr, Raleigh, NC 27609, United States

Courtyard by Marriott Raleigh Midtown

Stay at Courtyard by Marriott Raleigh Midtown with free WiFi, parking, and outdoor pool. Close to North Hills, museums, and Raleig...

4.1 (757) View
696 Shore Rd, North Truro, MA 02652, United States

Blue Sea Motor Inn

Relax at Blue Sea Motor Inn in North Truro, MA. Enjoy beachfront rooms with kitchenettes, free WiFi, pool access, and familyfrie...

4.1 (251) View
3208 Hill St, New Smyrna Beach, FL 32169, United States

Ocean Sands Beach Club

Ocean Sands Beach Club offers a 4.5star hotel experience with 151 guest reviews in New Smyrna Beach, FL. Ideal for a memorable be...

4.5 (151) View
191 Corinth Rd, Queensbury, NY 12804, United States

Red Roof Inn Queensbury

2.8rated Red Roof Inn Queensbury offers free WiFi, parking, and petfriendly rooms at 191 Corinth Rd, near West Mountain and Six...

2.8 (25) View
3768 US-65 #82, Lake Village, AR 71653, United States

Turn On Inn

Stay at Turn On Inn in Lake Village, AR. Rated 4.5 with 39 reviews. LGBTQ+ friendly hotel near Lake Chicot, Lake Chicot State Park...

4.5 (39) View
8399 Secrest Rd, Randolph, KS 66554, United States

Blue Vista

Blue Vista Hotel offers a 4.7 rating with 70 reviews near Randolph, KS. Close to Tuttle Creek Lake and state parks, ideal for sigh...

4.7 (70) View
702 US-2, Devils Lake, ND 58301, United States

Devils Lake Sportsmans Lodge

Stay at Devils Lake Sportsmans Lodge, a 4star motel in Devils Lake, ND. Petfriendly, kitchens in some rooms, free WiFi, and clo...

4 (63) View
Share your stay

Stayed at Motel 57? Help the next traveler decide.

Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.

Your email is only used to verify the review — it won't be shown publicly.