Located at 1161 Green Bay Rd in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin, Motel 57 offers a blend of motel comfort and hotel amenities with a 4.3-star rating based on 238 reviews. The property is noted for its clean, spacious rooms that include kitchenettes, making it suitable for visitors seeking convenience and practicality. Guests frequently mention the motel’s retro charm and the quiet, welcoming atmosphere created by the friendly staff.
The motel’s layout allows guests to park directly in front of their rooms, featuring outdoor seating areas and shared facilities like grills and a laundry room, which add to the convenience for longer stays or group visits. While some reviewers have noted minor inconsistencies in room quality, the overall experience is described as good value, especially for those who prefer a low-key alternative to large commercial hotels.
Motel 57 is LGBTQ+ friendly, welcoming a diverse range of guests. Its location serves well for those interested in sightseeing and recreational activities, supported by a mid-level score for ease of getting around. Nearby attractions include Potawatomi State Park and the Door County Maritime Museum, both popular for outdoor activities and cultural exploration. The Green Bay Austin Straubel International Airport is about a 52-minute drive away, facilitating access for travelers.
The property’s surroundings include several other lodging options within a few miles, providing choices depending on style and budget. Guest feedback highlights the motel as a sensible base for exploring Door County, especially for visitors who enjoy a calm setting with practical amenities like strong water pressure and pet-friendly policies.
Summary compiled by GoHotelly editors from verified guest reviews, partner descriptions and editorial notes.